Combining Respondr and Universality fragment layouts into Respondr-only

Owned by James Wennmacher (Deactivated)
Last updated: May 23, 2014

Overview

With the addition of Respondr and its regions feature (Respondr Regions Feature), uPortal layouts became a bit more complicated because uPortal has to support both Respondr and Universality/mUniversality layouts.

The non-respondr fragments are present for sites that will upgrade to 4.1 for other reasons, but are not prepared to invest in switching from Universality to Respondr. It gives them a migration path. The community was not prepared to force adopters and say they *had* to use Respondr.  Supporting both layouts also aids development by allowing a developer to fairly easily test a portlet to see how it looks in Respondr and Universality because you can pass a query string parameter to select the theme at login time.

Unfortunately in the default data set supporting both themes simultaneously makes the layout fragments a bit more complicated and confusing if you are using just Respondr and not Universality/mUniversality. If you are a Respondr user you have both fragment definitions apply:

Fragment/Layout fileApplies to
Unversality user		Applies to
Respondr User
guest-lo.fragment-definition.xml / guest-lo.fragment-layout.xmlXX
guest.respondr-lo.fragment-definition.xml / guest.respondr-lo.fragment-layout.xml X
authenticated-lo.fragment-definition.xml / authenticated-lo.fragment-layout.xmlXX
authenticated.respondr-lo.fragment-definition.xml / authenticated.respondr-lo.fragment-layout.xml X

Simplification

For a Respondr only site, these two sets can be collapsed into a single guest and authenticated view.  Move the Respondr-only content into the regular content; e.g. move the distinct content in guest.respondr-lo.fragment-layout.xml into guest-lo.fragment-layout.xml and authenticated.respondr-lo.fragment-layout.xml into authenticated-lo.fragment-layout.xml.  This allows you to simplify your layouts and delete the following files:

  • src/main/data/quickstart_entities/fragment-definition: guest.respondr-lo.fragment-definition.xml, authenticated.respondr-lo.fragment-definition.xml
  • src/main/data/quickstart_entities/fragment-layout: guest.respondr-lo.fragment-layout.xml,  authenticated.respondr-lo.fragment-layout.xml
  • src/main/data/quickstart_entities/user: guest.respondr-lo.user.xml, authenticated.respondr-lo.user.xml

When combining the layout files, do not have duplicates of the hidden="true" items.  The folders of type hidden="true" are not rendered for normal users, but are rendered for the layout owner to allow the layout owner to see the page and customize the page.  For example, both guest.respondr-lo.fragment-definition.xml and guest.respondr-lo.fragment-layout.xml have the following fragments:

Hidden folders render only for layout owners
<folder ID="s2" hidden="true" immutable="true" name="Page Top folder" type="page-top" unremovable="true">
    <channel fname="dynamic-respondr-skin" unremovable="false" hidden="false" immutable="false" ID="n3"/>
    <channel fname="fragment-admin-exit" unremovable="false" hidden="false" immutable="false" ID="n4"/>
</folder>
<folder ID="s5" hidden="true" immutable="true" name="Customize folder" type="customize" unremovable="true">
    <channel fname="personalization-gallery" unremovable="false" hidden="false" immutable="false" ID="n6"/>
</folder>

If you combine guest.respondr-lo.fragment-layout.xml into guest.respondr-lo.fragment-definition.xml the resulting file should not include the hidden="true" items from the guest.respondr-lo.fragment-layout.xml file or they would be duplicated.

Note that the approach of combining files and deleting the *respondr* versions works best if you had copied the quickstart_entities folder to your own institution-specific folder (and update build.properties to point to your institution-specific folder) and made the changes in your institution-specific folder.  This way merging in Apereo updates into your code base allows you to more easily inspect the changes made to the quickstart_entities in the code update and incorporate those you want in your version.